Karjala / Karelia kuuluu Suomelle - Pro Karelian fokus.
Karelia / Karelia is a part of Finland - Pro Karelia's focus.


Tietoa kirjoittajasta


Edvins Snore

Edvins Snore
Soviet Story -dokumenttifilmin tekijä ja ohjaaja
Kirjoittajan muita artikkeleita

19.04.2009
»  THE SOVIET STORY AND ITS CRITICS

  Lisää artikkeleita kirjoittajalta

  Artikkeli-arkisto




Include your email address to our Media, Political or Karelian list. You'll get information of the Karelian issue - mainly in Finnish.

Copyright 2008-2016 © Pro Karelia ry. You can copy the articles. Please mention the source of the article - Pro Karelia ry, www.prokarelia.net

  The personal registers of Pro Karelia

19.04.2009
Edvins Snore

THE SOVIET STORY AND ITS CRITICS

I am delighted that my film The Soviet Story is being screened in Finland. With respect to the Kremlin's accusations that the film glorifies Fascists, my suggestion is – “watch the film first, then you see for yourself what it stands for”.



Image texts, see below.

The Soviet Story condemns Fascism/Nazism. It condemns concentration camps and it condemns mass executions. However, as we now know, that it was not only Nazi Germany who operated concentration camps.

It was the Soviet Union as well. It had the largest concentration camp system in the world. Millions were exterminated in those camps. After the war the USSR even used the Nazi camps (Buchenwald, Sachsenhausen) as part of its own camp system – the GULAG.

The Soviet Story calls for persecution of those NKVD/KGB officers who worked in the GULAG and who carried out horrific torture, mutilations and executions of thousands of innocent victims both before and after World War II.

Everyone seems to agree that during Stalin's reign horrible crimes were committed. Yet no one has been held responsible for those crimes. Did Stalin himself singlehandedly torture and execute millions of people? None of the former NKVD/KGB criminals who actually committed the killings have been tried in Russia. Why have they escaped prosecution, whilst Nazi war criminals have been tried?

One man who might know the answer is Prime Minister Vladimir Putin. He has worked in the KGB. People who carried out torture and executions in 1930s/40s were his older colleagues. They worked in the KGB up until 1970s and 1980s. He has surely met them in the corridors of Lubianka.

They were the ones who did the actual crimes; whose hands were spattered with blood, literary. Putin's predecessor, the KGB Chief Ivan Serov, for example, was awarded the Order of Lenin – the highest State decoration - for orchestrating the mass murder of 20 000 unarmed people in 1940.

Not surprisingly, this is too uncomfortable a subject for the ex-KGB establishment which is currently in charge in Kremlin, to come to terms with.

It makes them nervous, when someone brings it up (e.g. in The Soviet Story). It is too difficult for them to reply to the simple question - “Why not condemn NKVD/KGB crimes and why not try the criminals who committed them”?

The Kremlin’s reaction to the film has thus been somewhat hysterical – aggressive public campaign against the Soviet Story culminating in a voodoo-style burning of the film director's effigy in the streets of Moscow.

When the first wave of emotions was over, Moscow apparently came up with a more sober strategy. This strategy was very simple: to label everyone who disagrees with Moscow - a Fascist. An old and proven Soviet method.

During the course of 70 years all opponents of Kremlin sooner or later were labeled Fascists – be they in Finland, Poland, Latvia, Ukraine, Georgia, Lithuania, Estonia, Korea, or even Japan.

The Soviet Story also reflects a point of view which is not shared by the Kremlin. As a result, the film is labeled as Fascist propaganda as well (even if the film describes Hitler and Nazism as criminal).

“Anti-Fascists” from Latvia, Estonia and Finland have also continuously criticized The Soviet Story. They may be from different European countries, but one thing unites them all – they all speak fluent Russian and they travel to Russia regularly.

Until recently the Anti-Fascist slogans of these pro-Kremlin groups frequently succeeded to trick naive Western journalists. However, in 2007, the anti-Fascist committee of Latvia blew its cover by engaging in open collaboration with Russian neo-Nazis in Latvia.

Both organizations – the neo-Nazis and anti-Fascists - held a joint nationalist gathering “The Russian March”. The move, which was criticized by moderate Russian politicians in Latvia, demonstrated that “Anti-Fascism” was just a cover for radical Russian nationalists to push their agenda in the countries bordering with Russia.



Dr. Backman together with Mr. Goncharov condemns the Soviet Story. Dr. Backman seems not disturbed by the fact that Goncharov leads an ultra-nationalist organization “Rodina”, whose website contains open hate-speech, such as appeals to kill Americans



In 2007 Neo-Nazi leader Osipov (right) together with Eduard Goncharov (left), leader of the Russian nationalist organization “Rodina” (Fatherland), and at the same time head of the “Latvian Anti-Fascist Committee”, - organized a nationalist gathering “Russian March” in Riga. The photo above is from the court proceedings after the event.



Image left: Eduard Goncharov, leader of the Anti-Fascist organization in Latvia
Image right: Eugene Osipov, leader of the Russian neo-Nazi organization in Latvia


Additional information: www.sovietstory.com






^  Takaisin ylös      Lisää artikkeleita kirjoittajalta      Artikkeli-arkisto 




Karjalan ja Petsamon palautus -kirja on julkaistu 14.10.2010 Tarton rauhan 90-vuotispäivänä.

Kirja käsittelee Suomen, Venäjän ja EU:n välisten suhteiden kannalta keskeisiä, vielä avoimia kysymyksiä: sotaan syyllisyys, sotasyyllisyys, evakkojen omaisuuden restituutio ja pakkoluovutettujen alueitten palautus.

Tilaa kirja Karelia Klubi Kaupasta, sähköposti tai 05 541 6450, hinta 19:50 euroa.









Koko Suomen kartta vuodesta 1920




Please transfer to Kansalaisvetoomus Internet site. This is an apply for the return of Karelia. It's not a membership form.







SIIRRY KARELIA KLUBI KAUPPAAN

Candomino laulaa karjalaisia lauluja [mp3-file].



SIIRRY KARELIA KLUBI KAUPPAAN

Karjalan satakielen Laps' olen Karjalan [4.9 MB mp3-file].